Prophecies of Zenos: Christ will be buried in a sepulcher/three days of darkness which would be a sign of his death to those on the Isles of the sea. Ethan Smith argues that the Native American traditions of a sacred book that was taken from them is in fulfillment of Amos 8:11 about the Lost Tribes of Israel having a famine of “hearing the words of the Lord.” He never argues that the Natives had the Old Testament with them in the Americas, but that these traditions refer to their time spent in ancient Israel (p. 47) [p. 115].
It was first published in 1823 (the Book of Mormon was published 6 years later in 1829). Of course, if someone is willing to make an argument about how the similarities cast aspersions on the authenticity of the Book of Mormon, I'd like to hear them. When the Book of Mormon is published in the 19th century and posits ideas that were in vogue specifically in the 19th century, that's a giant blinking red light that says, "Hey, this book is probably a product of the 19th century.". VOTH claims that the Ten Tribes were taken out of the Land of Canaan by the Assyrians in 725 B.C. VOTH claims that the Native Americans lost the word of God according to the prophecy of Amos 7:11,12. The BOM, instead, references animals such as horses, cattle, sheep, goats, cureloms, cumoms, and elephants.
“It is well known that laying the hand on the mouth, and the mouth in the dust, is a distinguished Hebraism.” The BOM never mentions this Hebraism. They came up with a criteria and then ran 130,000 contemporary works through it. The ten tribes may have brought phylacteries to the new world. The description bears no resemblance to the origin of the Book of Mormon or the Brass Plates, nor any of the other records mentioned in the Book of Mormon or LDS history. The BOM claims that Jesus Christ came to the Americas in 34 A.D. VOTH claims that the tradition of the Urim and Thummim can be found in Native American breastplates made of conch shells, elk beads and straps of otter skin. VOTH claims that the Americas were uninhabited since the great flood. Or, another way to look at it: What are the chances of finding a coincidence with so many possible coincidences? It's one thing for you to go through every match listed and say why you don't think it's that strong in your opinion - but you'd still have to confront the fact that this book has these kinds of matches in a statistically observable way that other volumes don't. Maybe you claim that the JST is a bad copy, but the JST claims that the KJV is a bad copy of some original text the JST had access to. ( Log Out / Say you claim that they are similar, so therefore the JST is unauthentic. The Brass Plates found in the BOM are a complicated record different from anything described by VOTH. I will set out to prove that the similarities between the two works are exaggerated and details are often contradictory. VOTH claims that those who came to the Americas traveled in a north-east direction from Canaan. VOTH says that an old Jewish Phylactery was written on dark yellow “leaves” of parchment, preserved much like ancient Arabian parchment. Identified as possibly referring to the Phylacteries used by ancient Israelites. They were most likely carried in small sacks, which is similar to the Ark of the Covenant. The BOM argues that the Americas were inhabited by the Jaredites after the confounding of languages at the Tower of Babel. Finding a new one was no doubt exciting for them. The BOM claims that the Nephites had brass plates that contained the writings of the prophets up until the reign of Zedekiah and were used to preserve the commandments of God and preserve the language of the people while in the Americas. They would The BOM never mentions this. Nevertheless, there is no evidence that Joseph Smith ever knew anything about this book. Mr. Frey (the celebrated Jewish preacher in this country) upon this subject; who could give no account of the incident from any Jewish custom. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account.
VOTH claims that the Ten Tribes came to the Americas by way of the Bering Strait, whereas the BOM asserts that they came by boat through the Arabian Sea. In addition, the book is comprised of the experiences of several individuals and institutions who had close contact with Native Americans and argue that their traditions are remarkably similar to Hebrew traditions. It is no wonder, then, that the Book of Mormon and VOTH would deal with such similar subject matter, even though they are completely separate and unique works. For the meantime, I will assume that the reader has a basic understanding of what is contained in both The View of the Hebrews (VOTH) and the Book of Mormon (BOM). Roberts privately researched the link between the Book of Mormon and the View of the Hebrews, Joseph’s father having the same dream in 1811 as Lehi’s dream, and other sources that were available to Joseph Smith, Oliver Cowdery, Martin Harris and others before the publication of the Book of Mormon. The BOM never mentions this Hebraism. For me, I usually don't find computational text analysis to be very robust - wordprint studies are used by critics and the faithful alike to prove the Book of Mormon's authorship in both directions. I would not be "shocked" to learn that someone believes the periodic table of elements is accurate, despite not going to a laboratory and repeating all the experiments to assure themselves that the atomic numbers are correct. Additional prophecies from unknown prophets Zenos, Zenock, Neum, Ezias, and unknown prophecies from Joseph and Jacob. (Alma 33:13) “Ye must believe what Zenos said; for, behold he said: Thou has turned away they judgments because of they Son.”. But having lost the knowledge of reading it, they concluded it would be of no further use to them; and they buried it with an Indian chief” (p. 90) [p. 223]. I'd like to point out the emperor with no clothes: The ONLY similarity between the Book of Mormon and the Late War are the 4-grams, and even looking at those, it is not even semantic similarities. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. He states: “An old Indian informed him that his fathers in this country had not long since had a book which they had for a long time preserved. The BOM asserts that the Brass Plates, a sacred book like the Bible, was written in reformed Egyptian and not the “divine speech.”. It doesn't appear in any feeds, and anyone with a direct link to it will see a message like this one. Prophecies of Jacob: Saw a ripped portion of Joseph’s coat, which had been preserved, and prophesied that a righteous branch would be preserved while the rest would be destroyed. The BOM never mentions these words or their likeness. He continues by stating that the Native Americans have traditions of the “longevity of the ancients” (p. 47) [p. 115] such as Adam and Methuselah, that there was a great flood and those who survived built “a great canoe” (p. 48) [p. 116], that they built a high place and “lost their language” (p. 48) [p. 116], that their ancestors “had a common father” with “twelve sons”, like the Biblical Jacob (p. 48) [p.116], that they had a “sanctified rod, which budded in one night’s time” like the rod of Moses (p. 48) [p. 116], they have feasts similar to pentecostal feasts (p. 48) [p.116-117], they never eat the “hollow of the thigh” of what they kill (p. 48) [p. 117], they give the first of their harvests to the Great Spirit (p. 49) [p. 119], they offer burnt sacrifices (p. 49) [p. 119-120], they have traditions of Abel being murdered by Cain (p. 49) [p. 120-121], they have a high priest who wears sacred ornaments and is anointed with bear’s oil (p. 49) [p. 121], the high priest makes a yearly atonement for sin (p. 50) [p. 121], they fast, abstain from sex and purify themselves before going to war (p. 50) [p. 122], they bury their dead with their fine belongings (p. 51) [p. 125], etc. To claim that the books themselves are similar because they share a high correlation of 4-grams is plain silly. Does this cast aspersions on the authenticity of either? This is mostly just academic. He in formed that the Jew s have a custom of burying their leaves of phylacteries when worn out and illegible; as they had also any old leaf of a Hebrew bible. Because of their wickedness, they lost the word of God and were attacked by the surrounding nations, but God had mercy on them and directed them to the Americas.
Numerous commentators on Mormon history, from LDS Church general authority B. H. Roberts to Fawn M. Brodie, biographer of Joseph Smith, have noted similarities in the content of View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon, which was first published in 1830, seven years after Ethan Smith's book.
This is going to be the most complete set of references you're asking for, so I'm not sure there's much value in copy/pasting them here. (Alma 33:3-11) Prophecies of Zenock: God will come to earth and will be killed by wicked and will be raised up/ (Alma 33:16) “For behold, he said: Thou art angry, O Lord, with this people, because they will not understand thy mercies which thou has bestowed upon them because of thy Son…and because the people would not understand his words they stoned him to death. Press J to jump to the feed.
People don't quote this study because they read the text in full. That's a pointless exercise anyway, since the study is based on computational results. The BOM claims that the savage Native Americans (Lamanites) rebelled against God and were jealous that their younger brother Nephi was a ruler over them.
( Log Out / I will set out to prove that the similarities between the two works are exaggerated and details are often contradictory.
( Log Out / VOTH claims that the Native Americans became savage and wicked because Providence was punishing them for the idolatry of the Ten Tribes of Israel. The BOM never mentions this Hebraism. Wherever they went then, they would have these phylacteries with them.
This quote comes as an isolated paragraph in a long list of “evidence” proving that Native American traditions have their origin in ancient Israel. That while they had this book things went well with them; they prospered exceedingly; but that other people got it from them; that the Indians lost their credit; offended the Great Spirit, and suffered exceedingly from the neighboring nations; and that the Great Spirit then took pity on them, and directed them to this country” (Smith,1825, http://www.thechristianidentityforum.net/downloads/View-America.pdf, p. 47 [p. 115]).
Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, https://www.fairmormon.org/answers/Book_of_Mormon/Plagiarism_accusations/The_Late_War. Signficiant similarity between two texts demonstrates that one is the source for the other, or else they have a common ancestor. They were possibly written on old dark yellow parchment similar to Arab parchment (p. 91). Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. “For behold, Laban hath the record of the Jews and also a genealogy of my forefathers, and they are engraven upon plates of brass.” (1 Nephi 3:3).
( Log Out / In the case of the Book of Mormon, if you can demonstrate that it used contemporary works as sources, then you can safely say it's not a pure translation of an ancient source.
Which Components Of Web Services Acts As A Directory, East Cleveland History, England U17 Football Squad 2020, Humiliated And Insulted Dostoevsky Pdf, When Was The 22nd Amendment Passed, Daniel In The Lions' Den Painting Meaning, Representational State Transfer, Rwby Volume 1 Complete, National Blood Donor Registry, Celebrity Iou Episode 2, Graham Richardson Marriage, Leukemia Volunteer Work, Add Frame To Photo Iphone, Couple App, Sandals With Straps Around Ankles, Isaiah, Joseph Smith, Whale In Forest, Athlon Argos Btr 1-4x24, 6th Earl Of Sefton, How To Pronounce Fart, Poetry Foundation School, Warren Huart Youtube, Abraham In Christianity, Orotund Mnemonic, Playford Dance Index, Battle Of Wauhatchie, Olivia Harrison Net Worth 2020, How Much Should I Pay Retailers For Selling My Product?, Mary Robinson Sappho And Phaon, Death Battle Season 5 Ranked, Meditations In An Emergency Audiobook, Open Toe Wedges, Utopia Lyrics, Escherichia Coli In Urine Treatment, Pluripotent Stem Cells Vs Totipotent, Florence Nightingale Transformational Leader, Best Gpu For Ryzen 3 3300x, Tej Pratap Yadav Qualification, World Cup Simulator 2022, Cricket Shirts, Paths Of Glory Cast, Rate George Harrison Albums, E Coli Origin, Alone 2020, Team Of Rivals Meaning, Platelet Donation Near Me, John Grey Of Groby, Scotland V Italy Rugby, Semantic Web Services Pdf, John Ashbery Our Youth, Whren V United States Pdf,
